Loans between a company and its shareholders: the presumption of article 35 is construed restrictively and covers only cash loans to shareholders. Does the deemed-interest presumption cover a loan the company makes to an individual who is not a direct shareholder, but is a shareholder of another company that holds shares in the lender? Colombia’s tax authority, the Dirección de Impuestos y Aduanas Nacionales (DIAN), through its Case Law Coordination office, answered in letter 100192467-3270 of October 27, 2026, in response to filing 2026DP000332875 of September 27, 2026. It is general doctrine: it does not resolve particular cases or provide specific advice. The source is a tax ruling; this article reads it from the perspective of the relationship between the company and its shareholders and is based solely on the text of the letter.
The inquiry: a loan to an indirect shareholder
The inquiry describes a lending company that advances money to an individual who is not its direct shareholder, but is a shareholder of another company that in turn holds shares in the lender. It asks whether, by reason of that indirect interest or of their status as beneficial owner, the minimum-yield presumption of article 35 of the Tax Code (Estatuto Tributario) must apply.
What the doctrine transcribed by DIAN says
The critical point: the presumption is conclusive, it is applied restrictively and only to the cases the legislature provided for, that is, cash loans between the company and its shareholders.
The letter answers with Official Letter 17162 of June 29, 2018: the presumption of article 35 does not admit evidence to the contrary, so it is applied restrictively and only to the cases provided for by the legislature, namely debts arising from cash loans (loan-for-consumption contracts, or mutuo) between companies and their shareholders. The letter states no express conclusion about the indirect shareholder or the beneficial owner: the answer follows from that restrictive reading, which anchors the rule in the relationship between the company and its shareholders.
In the words of the ruling: “The presumption set out in article 35 of the Tax Code is a conclusive presumption, that is, it does not admit evidence to the contrary and is therefore of restrictive application and only for the cases provided for by the legislature. […] the statutory provision is exclusive to debts arising from cash loans (loan-for-consumption contracts) between companies and shareholders and, consequently, only in such cases and for income tax purposes is the accrual of interest conclusively presumed”.
- Cash loans only: payables and receivables arising from transactions between the company and its shareholders, within the corporate purpose and the ordinary course of business, that are not cash loans do not generate the deemed interest of article 35 (Ruling 73045 of August 29, 2006, cited).
- Only between company and shareholders: the presumption is limited to that relationship. The letter does not extend the rule to a person who holds an interest indirectly through another company.
- Nature of the presumption: being conclusive, it does not admit evidence to the contrary; for that reason the interpreter cannot extend it to situations the legislature did not provide for.
- Scope of the letter: it is general, abstract doctrine; the petitioner must assess its applicability to the specific case. The text also refers to article 5 of the Tax Code and article 1.2.1.7.5 of Decree 1625 of 2016, without developing them.
A business example
Hypothetical case, with illustrative figures and applying only what the letter says. Comercializadora Delta S.A.S. has Holding Norte S.A.S. as its sole shareholder, and Holding Norte’s shareholder is Laura Pérez, an individual. Delta carries out three transactions:
- Lends COP 200 million in cash to Holding Norte, its direct shareholder: a cash loan between the company and a shareholder, the case article 35 covers.
- Lends COP 100 million in cash to Laura, a shareholder of Holding Norte but not of Delta: Laura is not a direct shareholder of Delta. Under the restrictive reading of the doctrine cited, the letter does not extend the presumption to the indirect shareholder; it does not say so expressly, so it is advisable to confirm it.
- Sells goods on credit to Holding Norte in the ordinary course of business: this is not a cash loan; the receivable does not generate deemed interest under article 35 (Ruling 73045 of 2006).
Fidelis Advisories’ recommendations
Fidelis Advisories’ own criteria, going beyond the text of the letter:
- Document every loan: formalize loans with the company in writing (amount, term, conditions) and make the cause of each receivable from shareholders clear.
- Internal approval: check in the bylaws and in the conflict-of-interest rules who must authorize loans to shareholders and related parties.
- Ownership map: keep the structure of direct and indirect shareholders and of the beneficial owner up to date.
- Mind the form: clearly distinguish a loan, an operating account, an advance and a distribution of profits; a wrong classification may bring corporate and tax consequences.
- Tax advice: since the presumption is a tax rule, confirm its effect in each case with the tax advisor; this article reads it only from the corporate side.
- Text and currency: consult the original letter and the rules cited before applying it to a specific case.
Consolidated opinion
Does the deemed-interest presumption of article 35 of the Tax Code apply to a loan from the company to an individual who is only a shareholder of the company’s shareholder? The letter’s answer: the presumption is conclusive and of restrictive application, only for cash loans between companies and shareholders; the letter makes no express statement about the indirect shareholder, but that restrictive reading does not extend it to them. Operating accounts that are not cash loans do not generate deemed interest either. In the Delta example, the loan to Holding Norte falls under article 35; the loan to Laura and the credit sale call for a different reading. This is general DIAN doctrine, which does not resolve particular cases.
This article is for information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Contact us about your specific case.
Facing a legal, tax or corporate decision?
Tell us about your case and a partner of the firm will outline the scope and a proposal.
